Sun. Feb 24th, 2019

The Border Patrol’s recruiting disaster

A Border Patrol agent takes Central American immigrants into custody in El Paso, Texas. Border Patrol’s struggles to recruit brokers have impeded the president’s efforts to lock down the border. | John Moore/Getty Photos


‘You’re down in actually harsh circumstances and you bought some migrants throwing rocks at you,’ Rep. Michael McCaul mentioned.

02/10/2019 05:00 PM EST

When President Donald Trump visits the Texas border city of El Paso on Monday, he’ll rejoice the work achieved by a regulation enforcement company whose workers enterprise to desolate landscapes, obtain lackluster extra time pay and encounter harmful conditions on daily basis.

Wish to be a part of?

Story Continued Under

Border Patrol’s struggles to recruit and hold brokers current a seldom-discussed obstacle to Trump’s efforts to lock down the U.S.-Mexico border — one which the Trump White Home is reluctant to acknowledge.

“It’s a troublesome job,” mentioned Rep. Michael McCaul, a Republican whose district stretches from outdoors Houston to the Austin space and is a former chairman of the Home Homeland Safety Committee. “You’re down in actually harsh circumstances and you bought some migrants throwing rocks at you.”

Shortly after taking workplace, the president signed an govt order that referred to as for the hiring of 5,000 brokers. Extra lately, his administration pushed a proposal that calls for two,750 extra brokers, regulation enforcement officers and employees. However Border Patrol can’t rent sufficient folks to fill jobs that had been obtainable earlier than. Whilst Congress gives funding to rent 21,370 brokers, the patrol is greater than 1,800 brokers in need of that mark.

Rep. Bennie Thompson (D-Miss.), chairman of the Homeland Safety Committee, mentioned the company’s incapability to spend its present allotment undercuts the Trump administration’s demand for extra brokers. “You make a greater argument whenever you say, ‘Look, we might use 5,000 extra as a result of we’re at our cap,’” he mentioned in an interview. “However you’re not there.”

The battle to recruit and retain Border Patrol brokers predates the Trump administration. The variety of brokers peaked at 21,444 in fiscal 12 months 2011, and since then has principally trended downward. U.S. Customs and Border Safety, the father or mother company to Border Patrol, persistently ranks close to the underside of an annual federal survey of worker satisfaction.

The company made some strides prior to now 12 months. Border Patrol counted 19,544 brokers in mid-January, a hard-won 107-agent enhance over the identical quantity in fiscal 12 months 2017.

“For the primary time in lots of, many, a few years, we’re hiring at a price that outpaces the speed at which we’re dropping,” Homeland Safety Secretary Kirstjen Nielsen advised lawmakers throughout a Senate committee listening to in October.

A CBP spokeswoman advised POLITICO that the company has labored in recent times to enhance its hiring course of with out affecting the standard of candidates, a key concern given its nationwide safety mission.

A protection spending invoice handed by Congress in December 2016 gave CBP the authority to waive the required polygraph examination for sure veterans. The company additionally made modifications to the polygraph testing course of. CBP’s lie-detector checks have created a hiring bottleneck prior to now and have the bottom cross price of any step within the company’s hiring course of, based on a June report by the Authorities Accountability Workplace.

A few of the modifications have been missteps. CBP awarded the consulting agency Accenture a $297 million contract in late 2017 to rent 7,500 brokers over 5 years — a complete that will exceed the demand in Trump’s govt order. Ten months into the contract, CBP had paid Accenture $13.6 million to course of two accepted job provides, based on an inside audit by the Homeland Safety Division inspector common’s workplace. CBP argued in a response to the report that Accenture had create a hiring construction and “recruited 1000’s of recent candidates.”

General, Border Patrol stays effectively under its funded staffing degree, which lawmakers and consultants counsel might stem from many components, together with work setting, pay and advantages.

Like different regulation enforcement officers, Border Patrol brokers face harmful conditions. Donna Doss, a 49-year-old Border Patrol agent primarily based in Abilene, Texas, died earlier this month after she was hit by a automobile whereas serving to state regulation enforcement with a visitors cease. An evaluation by the libertarian Cato Institute discovered 33 brokers had been killed on responsibility since 2003, not together with Doss.

The distant nature of patrol work might be off-putting for some folks, based on Victor Manjarrez, a former Border Patrol agent and present affiliate director of the Middle for Legislation and Human Conduct on the College of Texas at El Paso.

“In fact, within the desert, sound is amplified, and you can hear rocks rolling up forward,” he mentioned. “You realize there’s one thing up there and also you don’t know what on the planet it’s. The hair in your neck goes up. … And a few folks don’t like that.”

Chris Harris, an agent and former union consultant who retired in June, mentioned it’s arduous to recruit folks from main cities when they could find yourself in distant cities at or close to the Mexican border like Douglas, Ariz., or Lordsburg, N.M.

“Substandard housing, substandard medical, substandard colleges, in all probability not a job in your partner or important different,” Harris mentioned. “That’s a tough promote.”

A Border Patrol officer makes his rounds close to central El Paso on Dec. 23, 2018. | Paul Ratje/AFP/Getty Photos

Even individuals who benefit from the job are sometimes lured away by higher salaries elsewhere. Rep. Will Hurd (R-Texas) final 12 months sponsored a invoice to enhance the Border Patrol’s extra time pay course of. It handed the Home in September however died within the Senate.

Border Patrol brokers obtain much less profitable extra time pay than different federal regulation enforcement officers, a standard gripe for the Nationwide Border Patrol Council, a union that represents 14,000 brokers.

Earlier than 2016, Border Patrol brokers had entry to “administratively uncontrollable extra time,” which allowed them to obtain pay for work on the finish of a shift. However the profit was topic to widespread misuse and eradicated as a part of pay reform laws.

Brokers now can obtain extra time pay, however the price of pay doesn’t enhance for the additional hours. Officers with Immigration and Customs Enforcement, in the meantime, might be lined below the Truthful Labor Requirements Act and obtain time and a half for his or her extra time hours, identical to overtime-eligible workers within the personal sector.

Brandon Judd, president of the Border Patrol union and a Trump ally, mentioned pay parity might stem the tide of agent departures. “For those who don’t tackle that difficulty,” he mentioned, “you’ll by no means tackle the attrition downside.”

Border Patrol brokers frequently hop to different regulation enforcement businesses, together with ICE and the CBP Workplace of Discipline Operations, which handles customs and manages ports of entry, based on the June GAO report.

ICE is an interesting possibility for Border Patrol brokers, based on the report. Of 113 brokers who left for different businesses within the first half of fiscal 12 months 2018, 64 p.c went to ICE.



One cause is that ICE maintains a Homeland Safety Investigations unit that gives higher incomes alternatives to brokers with a bachelor’s diploma or larger. Border Patrol has no such investigative unit. Another excuse, the report mentioned, is that “working a typical day shift at ICE in a managed indoor setting positioned in a serious metropolitan space” is “a sexy profession different for Border Patrol brokers who typically work evening shifts in excessive climate in geographically distant places.”

Some blame Trump for Border Patrol’s incapability to draw and retain employees.

The president’s contentious insurance policies can damage morale, argues Todd Breasseale, a DHS official below President Barack Obama. Border Patrol brokers helped execute Trump’s “zero tolerance” coverage final 12 months, which break up aside 1000’s of households and ignited widespread condemnation.

“You’ve got a regulation enforcement company that America wants, however it’s a device that must be used appropriately,” Breasseale mentioned.

Rep. Joaquín Castro, a Texas Democrat and the chairman of the Congressional Hispanic Caucus, blames the administration’s quest to construct a border wall. “They need to be targeted on ensuring the company is correctly staffed, committing their time and power to that.”

Castro and different Democratic lawmakers traveled to frame areas in New Mexico in December and January to , and noticed circumstances after two migrant kids died in Border Patrol custody.

“The brokers had been telling us that oftentimes they’re patrolling areas with out radio communication and even cellphone communication,” Castro advised POLITICO. “It was clear that the company isn’t staffed with the medical provides and coaching and personnel they should maintain someone in the event that they encounter an emergency. … So yeah, it’s a powerful job in that means.”

Others say Trump’s insurance policies have been a plus for Border Patrol’s rank and file. The president has proven a powerful affinity for the Border Patrol union, which endorsed him in 2016. Trump even introduced Judd and different union members into the White Home in the course of the current 35-day authorities shutdown over Trump’s demand of $5.7 billion for a border wall. Judd mentioned that brokers have observed Trump’s dedication to their mission.

“They are going to 100 p.c inform you that they really feel appreciated,” he mentioned.

Judd contends Trump’s divisive immigration agenda hasn’t made it more durable to retain brokers. Those that stay, he mentioned, see the president’s immigration crackdown not as a disadvantage however as a morale booster. “Those that keep,” he mentioned, “they have an inclination to consider within the mission.”

This text tagged below:

Lacking out on the newest scoops? Join POLITICO Playbook and get the newest information, each morning — in your inbox.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *