California Gov. Gavin Newsom on Monday introduced an govt order that requires steps to cut back youth entry to vaping merchandise. | Justin Sullivan/Getty Photos
The chief is combating to overturn San Francisco’s ban on all e-cigs by way of a November poll initiative — and different cities are watching.
SAN FRANCISCO — A number of California cities are swiftly shifting past flavored vape bans to outlaw e-cigarette gross sales totally, following within the footsteps of Juul’s hometown of San Francisco.
It’s an indication that the Trump administration’s crackdown on the fast-growing vaping might be simply the beginning of its issues.
Story Continued Under
San Francisco was the primary of three California cities to ban e-cigarettes altogether. About two dozen different California cities have banned flavored vapes, and states and communities throughout the nation are following go well with because the Trump administration strikes to take the merchandise off the market.
Juul already has spent greater than $four.5 million making an attempt to persuade voters to overturn San Francisco’s first-in-the-nation e-cigarette ban with a November poll initiative. It’s engaged on a repeal effort of the same measure in a smaller close by metropolis.
If San Francisco’s broad ban prevails on the poll field, it’s going to seemingly encourage extra cities and states to take daring measures. Simply final week, a 3rd California metropolis voted to finish all e-cigarette gross sales.
“This isn’t simply loopy San Francisco saying that e-cigarettes are unhealthy for people, notably unhealthy for our younger folks,” mentioned metropolis Supervisor Shamann Walton, who wrote the town ordinance that banned e-cigarettes. “We have to do the whole lot that we will to maintain them out of the fingers of our youth right here in San Francisco and proceed work to be sure that occurs throughout the state and throughout the nation.”
By signing up you comply with obtain e-mail newsletters or alerts from POLITICO. You’ll be able to unsubscribe at any time.
The e-cigarette firm is countering with a message about grownup alternative, notably for people who smoke on the lookout for one thing that’s much less dangerous than conventional cigarettes.
“Prohibition doesn’t work, and this ban for all adults will assist gasoline a harmful black marketplace for vapor merchandise and drive grownup people who smoke again to cigarettes, which kill 40,000 Californians each single yr and are the main reason behind preventable demise on the earth,” Juul spokesperson Ted Kwong mentioned in an announcement to POLITICO.
The current publicity about youth vaping, mixed with the outbreak of a thriller vaping-related illness that’s killed at the very least six and sickened almost 400 folks, has taken its toll on public opinion. Morning Seek the advice of reported Monday that the share of Individuals who view Juul unfavorably is greater than 5 instances greater than it was in July 2018. Of the 1,900 manufacturers tracked, Juul is now second to final in recognition. Solely Marlboro is worse.
Matthew Myers, president of the Marketing campaign for Tobacco-Free Youngsters, mentioned he sees taste bans, moderately than all-out prohibitions, as the first approach state and native governments will push the federal authorities for decisive motion. But when that does not occur, all bets could also be off, notably given public concern over the current vaping-related sickness.
“There was rising second for the necessity for sturdy authorities motion, each to curtail the explosion in youth use and to get to backside of the current critical sicknesses,” Myers mentioned. “Until cities and states see an actual change, then they will proceed to search for options that defend their residents.”
After President Donald Trump’s announcement on the White Home final week, FDA officers informed lawmakers that the company will subject guidelines inside weeks, giving e-cigarette makers 30 days to tug flavored merchandise off the market or face fines. Solely merchandise that obtain FDA approval could be allowed again available on the market after company overview.
The CDC on Monday activated its emergency operations middle to bolster the interagency response to the mysterious lung sickness linked to vaping.
A lot of the anti-vaping motion has been pushed by native governments with some 30 cities nationwide — together with 22 in California — already enacting complete taste restrictions, together with merchandise that comprise menthol. Greater than 200 jurisdictions across the nation now implement some type of restrictions round e-cigarettes to deal with youth vaping.
California Gov. Gavin Newsom on Monday introduced an govt order that requires steps to cut back youth entry to vaping merchandise and a $20 million public well being training marketing campaign about tobacco and hashish. However he stopped in need of calling for a ban on flavored tobacco merchandise.
San Francisco was the primary main metropolis to undertake a complete taste ban in 2017, and metropolis voters final yr overwhelmingly rejected a virtually $12 million tobacco industry-funded poll measure looking for its repeal.
Then the town supervisors went past the flavored ban, making historical past in June by passing essentially the most restrictive e-cigarette measure within the nation. It might droop gross sales of all vaping merchandise till they endure overview by the FDA, a course of that would take years.
Juul rapidly funded a profitable drive to place an initiative, Proposition C, on the town’s November poll that seeks to overturn the ban and change it with a set of gross sales restrictions the corporate helps.
For Juul, taste restrictions could also be robust sufficient — the corporate mentioned it already shifted the gross sales of its “non-traditional” flavors out of retail places — however full gross sales prohibitions take it to a different stage.
Kwong, the Juul spokesperson, mentioned the corporate was “dissatisfied” the 2 different Bay Space cities — Livermore and Richmond — “took the identical path” as San Francisco, as an alternative of specializing in “the chance to enact robust and efficient regulation that can stop youth entry.”
Juul’s technique is to work with municipalities to keep away from banning any merchandise, preferring to push for stricter point-of-sales laws. The corporate factors to new digital techniques that make it tougher for e-cigarettes to be offered illegally to minors and restrict the quantity folks can buy. Firm officers mentioned they’ve already put in 50 at shops in San Francisco and about 5 in Livermore, along with updating 1000’s of techniques across the nation.
The corporate can also be emphasizing the merchandise as a approach to assist grownup people who smoke transition from conventional cigarettes, an strategy that some public well being consultants help however stays controversial. Two days earlier than Trump’s taste ban was introduced, the FDA warned Juul in opposition to advertising and marketing its vapes as a lot safer than tobacco merchandise with out company approval to take action.
If all else fails, Juul will seemingly contemplate authorized motion in opposition to the cities that ban their merchandise, in response to a supply near the corporate.
Whereas the gross sales prohibitions stay restricted to the Bay Space, Trump’s transfer and the spurt of motion by different communities is creating a much more troublesome surroundings for the vaping . That makes the end result of San Francisco’s poll measure much more important.
“This motion is actual from a grassroots perspective as a result of mother and father are feeling it in each neighborhood,” mentioned Larry Tramutola, a political strategist working a marketing campaign in opposition to Juul’s poll measure. “Native jurisdictions are looking for options to those issues, and I feel Juul has been a bit of caught off guard.”
Richmond Mayor Tom Butt, whose metropolis authorized a complete ban on e-cigarette gross sales, mentioned the destiny of the San Francisco poll measure might decide whether or not extra cities comply with this path. And he mentioned he is not shocked that the motion in opposition to all e-cigarette gross sales has began within the area.
“California is mostly within the entrance of the remainder of nation, and the Bay Space is out in entrance of California,” he mentioned.
This text tagged underneath:
Lacking out on the newest scoops? Join POLITICO Playbook and get the newest information, each morning — in your inbox.