A number of strains of inquiry that Particular Counsel Robert Mueller and the FBI — to not point out numerous journalists and newbie Web sleuths — had reportedly been pursuing went unaddressed within the copious doc. | Alex Wong/Getty Pictures
Over 448 pages, particular counsel Robert Mueller’s closing report lined an enormous quantity of floor, from Trump marketing campaign contacts with Russian operatives to President Donald Trump’s efforts to thwart Mueller’s probe.
However whereas Mueller discovered that the Trump marketing campaign didn’t conspire with the Russian authorities, he didn’t resolve each thriller surrounding the Kremlin’s 2016 election interference scheme.
Story Continued Under
A number of strains of inquiry that Mueller and the FBI — to not point out numerous journalists and newbie Web sleuths — had reportedly been pursuing went unaddressed within the copious doc. They embrace mysterious interactions between the Trump Group and Alfa Financial institution pc servers; the interior workings of the information mining agency Cambridge Analytica; and influence-peddling by Center Jap international locations focusing on Trump’s fledgling administration. Different avenues, like whether or not compromising tapes exist of the president and what a Russian oligarch did with the interior Trump marketing campaign polling knowledge he was given, had been left open-ended.
It’s potential that some or all of those matters are being examined by federal prosecutors impartial of Mueller’s workplace. Mueller revealed in his report that international intelligence and counterintelligence data was usually transferred to FBI headquarters or subject workplaces. Mueller additionally made 14 legal referrals to the Justice Division and bureau. Solely two of these referrals — involving Trump’s former private lawyer Michael Cohen and former Obama White Home counsel Greg Craig — are publicly recognized.
POLITICO Playbook publication
Enroll immediately to obtain the #1-rated publication in politics
By signing up you comply with obtain e-mail newsletters or alerts from POLITICO. You may unsubscribe at any time.
It appears clear that none of these subplots prompted Mueller’s crew to contemplate bringing legal fees. However whereas Mueller’s unique mandate directed him to pursue each a counterintelligence investigation and a legal probe, his report accommodates no labeled data, leaving unknown to the general public something he might need found in that class.
Listed here are 5 of the most important unresolved subplots of the Russia investigation:
Did a secret pc hyperlink exist between the Trump Group and Moscow’s Alfa Financial institution?
Even earlier than Mueller was appointed, the FBI was analyzing why a pc server for Alfa Financial institution, Russia’s largest industrial financial institution — led by oligarchs with shut ties to Russian President Vladimir Putin — had 1000’s of contacts with a server utilized by the Trump Group between Might and September of 2016. A Slate report on the contacts primarily based on analysis by pc scientists precipitated a web-based sensation simply days earlier than the election, till the New York Occasions reported that the FBI had concluded there might be what the paper known as an “innocuous rationalization” for the exercise, like a advertising e-mail or spam.
Many impartial cybersecurity researchers and specialists, lots of whom labored at senior ranges within the Pentagon, White Home, and intelligence group, have continued to insist that the timing and frequency of the server exercise was not according to an automatic course of. “The timing of the communication was not random, and it wasn’t regular-periodic,” one researcher informed informed the New Yorker final October. “It was a greater match for human exercise.”
Innocuous or not, the server exercise shouldn’t be addressed within the Mueller report in any respect. The one dialogue of Alfa Financial institution comes inside the context of efforts by its CEO, Petr Aven, to attach with the Trump transition crew in December 2016. These efforts had been apparently unsuccessful, in accordance with Mueller, which can have led the particular counsel’s workplace to dismiss the pc server exercise as inconsequential. However there’s nonetheless no conclusive rationalization for the pinging, or why the Trump area that Alfa was contacting abruptly disappeared two days after the New York Occasions notified Alfa’s representatives in Washington of the server exercise.
Did Cambridge Analytica have ties to Russia or WikiLeaks?
One of many greatest subplots of the investigations into Russian election interference is the position the information mining agency Cambridge Analytica. However the controversial firm didn’t seem as soon as within the report, regardless of indications that Mueller had questioned and subpoenaed former workers.
The Trump marketing campaign employed Cambridge Analytica in the summertime of 2016, and it performed a key position in making an attempt to sway voters utilizing pilfered Fb knowledge through the election.
Aleksandr Kogan, a Russian-American who labored on the College of Cambridge, helped the agency harvest the uncooked knowledge of as much as 87 million Fb profiles starting in 2014, which the corporate then used to micro-target political adverts. There’s a WikiLeaks connection, too: Alexander Nix, the corporate’s CEO, has acknowledged reaching out to Assange in the summertime of 2016 to supply his assist in organizing any Hillary Clinton-related emails WikiLeaks deliberate to launch.
Mueller subpoenaed Brittany Kaiser, the previous enterprise growth director for the agency, earlier this 12 months. She informed The Guardian that she was absolutely cooperating. Sam Patten, a Washington-based operative who started cooperating with Mueller’s probe final 12 months after pleading responsible to an unrelated cost, labored on the Oregon workplace of Cambridge Analytica’s mother or father firm, SCL Group, in runup to the 2014 midterm elections. And Mueller quizzed a number of digital specialists who labored on Trump’s marketing campaign concerning the big-data agency, in accordance with ABC.
Just like the NRA, nevertheless, Cambridge Analytica shouldn’t be talked about in any respect in Mueller’s report. As such, it’s nonetheless unclear what, if something, the corporate knew about WikiLeaks’ plans or whether or not its micro-targeting efforts had been coordinated with the Russian’s data warfare marketing campaign.
Intriguingly, although, a lot of the portion of Mueller’s report coping with Russia’s Web Analysis Company — which tasked web “trolls” with spreading disinformation and propaganda through the election — was redacted within the closing report due to potential hurt to ongoing investigations.
What was the NRA’s relationship with the Trump marketing campaign, and with Russia?
Because the election, there have been quite a few however imprecise knowledge factors indicating the Russians is likely to be making an attempt to infiltrate the Nationwide Rifle Affiliation as a solution to join with Republicans and Trump’s marketing campaign.
Mueller’s report, nevertheless, did not shed any gentle on the topic, regardless of media reviews that the particular counsel was poking round on the topic.
The primary indication of Mueller’s curiosity within the potential ties got here earlier this 12 months, when former Trump marketing campaign adviser Sam Nunberg informed CNN the particular counsel’s crew had requested him concerning the marketing campaign’s relationship with the NRA and the circumstances of a Trump speech there in 2015. The investigators continued asking witnesses concerning the marketing campaign’s ties to the NRA as not too long ago as December 2018, in accordance with CNN.
And final July’s indictment of Maria Butina, a Russian nationwide who sought to infiltrate each the Trump marketing campaign and the NRA through the election, additionally raised questions concerning the group’s standing as a possible middleman between Trump and the Russians. Butina was charged with performing as an agent of a international authorities with out notifying the Justice Division.
Butina was the primary particular person to ask Trump in public about his place on Russian sanctions throughout a 2015 occasion in Las Vegas, and tried to dealer a gathering between Trump and her Russian handler, Alexander Torshin, at an NRA conference in Might 2016.
McClatchy later reported that FBI counterintelligence investigators had been investigating whether or not Torshin laundered cash from Russia into the NRA to assist fund Trump’s marketing campaign — the NRA spent $30 million to assist Trump in 2016, triple what it spent on supporting Mitt Romney in 2012.
Regardless of the investigators’ curiosity, nevertheless, the gun-rights group was not talked about a single time in Mueller’s report. And her case was dealt with by prosecutors in Washington, D.C., not by Mueller’s crew.
What did WikiLeaks know concerning the supply of the stolen emails?
Mueller did reply one lingering query about Russian election hacking — how Kremlin brokers bought their digitally pilfered emails to WikiLeaks.
However he didn’t deal with the extra probably damning query: Did WikiLeaks understand it was getting the fabric from Russian cutouts?
In his report, Mueller outlines intimately how Russia’s army intelligence company, the GRU, hacked Democrats through the marketing campaign. Between March and April of 2016, the report says, “the GRU stole lots of of 1000’s of paperwork from the compromised e-mail accounts and networks” and disseminated them each by GRU brokers posing as impartial hackers — together with “Guccifer 2.zero” and DCLeaks.com — and WikiLeaks.
In response to Mueller’s report, the GRU used these faux on-line personas to shuttle a few of their stolen cache to WikiLeaks. Via DCLeaks, the GRU initiated a dialog with WikiLeaks about transferring stolen paperwork on June 16, 2016. Eight days later, WikiLeaks reached out to Guccifer 2.zero by way of Twitter and requested for “any new materials.”
Mueller famous that Assange and WikiLeaks tried to obscure the supply of the hacked supplies by claiming in public statements that the DNC hack was an “inside job” carried out by Seth Wealthy, a murdered committee staffer, slightly than by Russia.
However the particular counsel’s workplace both wouldn’t or couldn’t clarify what WikiLeaks knew concerning the true id of the hackers.
“Each the GRU and WikiLeaks sought to cover their communications, which has restricted the Workplace’s capacity to gather the entire communications between them,” the report says, pointing to their use of encryption.
That data might be related to figuring out whether or not WikiLeaks acted in a journalistic capability, as its founder Julian Assange has maintained, or as a “non-state hostile intelligence service” abetted by Russia, as then-CIA Director Mike Pompeo claimed in April 2017.
Assange was arrested in London earlier this month after Ecuador withdrew his asylum. He faces U.S. legal fees for allegedly making an attempt to assist former U.S. intelligence analyst Chelsea Manning crack into a pc storing delicate authorities information in 2010.
What concerning the notorious video tape alleged within the Steeele file?
Maybe no aspect of the Trump-Russia scandal was as sensational because the declare, contained in an unverified file assembled through the marketing campaign by former British spy Christopher Steele, that the Russians had kompromat on Trump within the former of video capturing him cavorting with prostitutes in a Moscow resort room.
Though the alleged tape consumed huge public consideration over the previous two years, Mueller mentions it solely briefly. His report states that Russian businessman Giorgi Rtskhiladze texted Michael Cohen on October 30, 2016 and mentioned: “Stopped stream of tapes from Russia however undecided if there’s the rest. Simply so you already know …. ” Rtskhiladze informed investigators that “tapes” referred to derogatory tapes of Trump rumored to be within the possession of the Agalarovs—a Russian-Azerbaijani household that hosted the Miss Universe pageant in Moscow in 2013.
Rtskhiladze informed Mueller that he believed the tapes had been faux. However for no matter cause, he didn’t inform that to Cohen, in accordance with the report. Mueller doesn’t draw a conclusion by some means. It stays unclear who might need been creating or disseminating such tapes, what their motive might need been — and whether or not anybody on Mueller’s crew ever noticed a number of of them.
This text tagged below:
Lacking out on the most recent scoops? Join POLITICO Playbook and get the most recent information, each morning — in your inbox.