In a victory for Apple, the Supreme Court docket on Monday refused to listen to an attraction by the College of Wisconsin over a case involving chips in iPhones and iPads.
The case made headlines in 2015 when a jury sided with the college’s claims that Apple had infringed on its patents. The court docket ordered Apple to pay $234 million in damages.
In 2017, a choose greater than doubled the decision to $506 million after discovering Apple owed both $1.61 or $2.34 in royalties for each system it offered.
Final 12 months, Apple, nevertheless, persuaded the Court docket of Appeals for the Federal Circuit to throw out the ruling. The court docket, which is liable for all patent appeals within the nation, tossed the decision after concluding “no cheap juror may have discovered infringement based mostly on the proof offered.”
The Federal Circuit’s conclusion turned on the esoteric query of how the phrase “specific” ought to apply to questions of information administration involving the chips.
In its attraction, the College of Wisconsin mentioned the Federal Circuit wrongfully reinterpreted a query that ought to have been left to the jury—a place echoed by some distinguished patent students.
The Supreme Court docket’s resolution to not hear the case means the College of Wisconsin is out of authorized choices, and Apple has received the case.
The college, which manages its patents by means of an entity known as the Wisconsin Alumni Analysis Basis (WARF), has confronted controversy up to now for its aggressive assertion of its mental property. Critics say its techniques parallel these of so-called patent trolls, which pursue lawsuits regardless of not implementing the innovations described of their patents. Defenders say the patent lawsuits filed by WARF and different universities are an essential for commercializing precious analysis.
Neither Apple nor WARF instantly responded to a request for remark.
Extra must-read tales from Fortune:
—Domino’s delivers a dilemma to the Supreme Court docket: a web site accessibility case that might affect hundreds of firms
—How Russian PR corporations plant tales for firms in U.Okay. information retailers, social media
—Why Tesla quietly acquired DeepScale, a machine studying startup that’s ‘squeezing’ A.I.
—Comcast, Mastercard, and Samsung are pouring tens of millions into this password-killing startup
—Why Apple is providing cheaper streaming and iPhones
Meet up with Information Sheet, Fortune’s day by day digest on the enterprise of tech.