Although Lil Nas X has damaged chart information and turn into a streaming juggernaut together with his breakout nation rap hit “Previous City Highway” with Billy Ray Cyrus, the tune faces an uphill problem to get a nomination for a CMA award.
Ballots have gone out for nominations for the Nation Music Affiliation Awards, however some voters are struggling to determine how one can acknowledge the musical phenomenon of the 12 months, which has turn into the longest operating No. 1 tune within the historical past of Billboard’s Scorching 100.
Billboard determined “Previous City Highway” wasn’t a rustic tune and pulled it off nation charts early on, however the tune made sufficient of an affect anyway that it turned eligible for quite a few CMA classes this 12 months, together with single of the 12 months and tune of the 12 months. CMA voters, which embody musicians, producers, songwriters, touring professionals, nation radio staff and others, vote in three ballots with the ultimate nominations sometimes being introduced in late August or early September. The award present will air Nov. 13.
However there are already indicators that the tune is not getting vast help. It didn’t get sufficient votes within the main tune classes. The tune solely earned sufficient votes to be thought of within the musical occasion class on the second poll, which went out to voters Monday.
Shane McAnally, certainly one of nation’s largest hit-makers who has written for Sam Hunt, Kacey Musgraves, Kenny Chesney and extra, mentioned he is been impressed with the way in which the tune has resonated with followers, nevertheless it by no means felt nation to him.
“I simply suppose nation folks don’t see that as a rustic tune,” mentioned McAnally, who’s co-president of Monument Information and certainly one of three producers on NBC’s tune competitors collection, “Songland.” ”Pop listeners suppose it is a nation tune.”
The tune’s genreless method by mixing lure beats with a 9 Inch Nails pattern and Western-themed lyrics appealed to millennials on TikTok however took Nashville’s music trade without warning. Whereas pop, rap and rock artists have gotten CMA nominations earlier than, it is quite a bit tougher to earn a nomination with out broad help amongst Nashville’s labels and nation radio.
Nelly was nominated for musical occasion in 2013 with Florida Georgia Line for “Cruise,” however that was a rustic tune with a rapper added to the remix. Nelly’s earlier collaboration with Tim McGraw on “Over and Over” in 2004, which was primarily promoted as a rap tune, didn’t earn any nominations from the CMAs.
“I might be shocked if it makes the ultimate poll,” McAnally mentioned of “Previous City Highway.”
Nonetheless McAnally identified that non-country acts can nonetheless shock on the CMA Awards, corresponding to when John Denver, largely thought of a pop-folk artist, gained entertainer of the 12 months in 1975, prompting Charlie Wealthy to set fireplace to the cardboard with Denver’s title throughout the broadcast.
David Macias, president of Nashville-based leisure firm Thirty Tigers, which works with Americana artists like Jason Isbell and John Prine, mentioned Billboard’s choice to not classify the tune as nation most likely simply strengthened CMA voters who weren’t inclined to vote for it anyway.
“I have not actually determined what I’m going to do the place that is involved,” Macias mentioned. “There is not any doubt it is the musical cultural phenomenon of the 12 months. I’m on the fence on whether or not or not it sits in there. It deserves some recognition, and albeit it doesn’t matter what occurs on the voting half, it is going to be attention-grabbing to see what the CMA does.”
Hunter Kelly, a veteran nation music journalist, was stunned that the tune did not get sufficient early votes for single of the 12 months, however he mentioned its qualifications for the musical occasion class appeared plain.
“For those who discuss a musical occasion, it is nonetheless 19 weeks at No. 1,” Kelly mentioned. “It is the all-time No. 1 on the Scorching 100, in order a musical occasion, it completely deserves a nomination.”
In the course of the voting interval, labels or administration businesses usually interact in lobbying efforts that embody commercials in music trade publications. Representatives for Lil Nas X’s label, Columbia Information, didn’t reply to the AP for remark in regards to the CMA voting.
Kelly mentioned that since “Previous City Highway” did not originate in Nashville and Lil Nas X just isn’t signed to a Nashville label, there’s fewer voters emotionally or financially invested in seeing it get nominated.
On the very least, “Previous City Highway” has proved that lightning can strike twice in the identical place with the re-introduction of Billy Ray Cyrus to a brand new era, McAnally mentioned. The mullet-wearing Cyrus was final nominated for a CMA in 1992 when he gained single of the 12 months for his personal ubiquitous, danceable hit “Achy Breaky Coronary heart.”
“That is fairly loopy,” McAnally mused. “He wasn’t going away. You possibly can’t low cost that.”
Extra must-read tales from Fortune:
—Inside Danny Trejo’s odyssey from ex-con character actor to taco mogul
—Documentaries stand out in a summer season field workplace filled with sequels
—The merger of Viacom and CBS might dim Netflix’s rising star
—How a forensic handwriting professional will look at Aretha Franklin’s will
—Neglect wine and tequila, celebs are launching sake manufacturers now
Comply with Fortune on Flipboard to remain up-to-date on the newest information and evaluation.